Skip to content

Black Hills Parks & Forests Association

Which Black Hills Cave Tour Is Right for You


Wind Cave + Jewel Cave • Choosing a tour

Which Black Hills cave tour is right for you

Between the two cave parks there are ten different ways underground, from a flat 20-minute room to a four-hour crawl. Most visitors pick blind. You do not have to.

Tours to choose from
10
across both caves
Easiest
20 min
Discovery: step-free upper platform available
Hardest
4 hours
on your hands and knees
Most stairs
734
Jewel Cave Scenic Tour
Between caves
~45 min
many do both in a day

The Black Hills hold two of the world’s great caves, and both put you underground only on a ranger-guided tour. This guide sorts the tours by the things that actually decide a good visit: how long, how hard, how many stairs, what you see, and whether it fits kids, knees, and a fear of tight spaces.

Short version: if you want one classic cave walk and no surprises, book the Natural Entrance Tour at Wind Cave or the Scenic Tour at Jewel Cave. If someone in your group cannot do stairs, choose Jewel Cave’s Discovery Tour or Wind Cave’s Accessibility Tour. If you want a hard, muddy adventure, that is the Wild Cave Tour (Wind) or the Wild Caving Tour (Jewel). The full table and the by-situation picks are below.

Wind Cave or Jewel Cave: which cave should I choose?

If you can only fit one, here is the honest breakdown.

  • Choose Wind Cave if you want a classic national-park cave experience with a range of tour lengths, more boxwork than all other caves on Earth combined (the delicate honeycomb fins Wind Cave is famous for), and a large free surface park with bison, prairie, and scenic drives to fill the rest of the day.
  • Choose Jewel Cave if you want the more decorated cave. Jewel Cave is the fifth longest cave in the world, with more than 220 miles of mapped passages, the Scenic Tour shows off dense calcite crystal, and a lot of visitors quietly rate it the better cave. It gets less attention because it is “only” a monument, which is exactly why repeat Black Hills travelers tell each other not to skip it.

You can plan a two-cave day if the tour times and drive fit. The visitor centers connect by US 385 and US 16 through Custer. Book both tours ahead and leave room for wildlife delays and each park’s check-in time. There is more on the two-cave day below.

Compare every Black Hills cave tour

Times, stair counts, and rules were verified against the National Park Service in July 2026. Every tour is ranger-guided. Confirm the exact schedule when you book, since the parks adjust tours by season.

Every cave tour at Wind Cave and Jewel Cave, easiest to hardest
Tour Cave Time Stairs & difficulty Good for How to book
Discovery Tour Jewel 20 min Easiest One large chamber by elevator; 15 steps to the lower platform or a step-free upper platform; strollers allowed Limited mobility, very young kids, low time or energy recreation.gov
Accessibility Tour Wind 30 min No stairs Elevator to a level 100-foot section; wheelchair accessible Wheelchair users, anyone who cannot do stairs Phone, 605-745-4600
Garden of Eden Tour Wind 1 hr Moderate 150 stairs, 1/4 mile, elevator in and out First cave tour, shorter walk, kids who can do stairs recreation.gov
Natural Entrance Tour Wind 1 hr 15 min Moderate 300 stairs, 2/3 mile, exits by elevator The default first-timer pick at Wind Cave; the famous boxwork recreation.gov
Scenic Tour Jewel 1 hr 20 min Mod. strenuous 734 stairs, 1/2 mile paved loop, elevator in and out The default first-timer pick at Jewel Cave; the most decorated route recreation.gov
Fairgrounds Tour Wind 1 hr 30 min Strenuous 450 stairs incl. one 89-step flight up, 2/3 mile Able walkers who want the most cave on a standard tour recreation.gov
Historic Lantern Tour Jewel 1 hr 45 min Strenuous ~600 steep, narrow stairs, lantern-lit, historic entrance Older kids (8+) and adults who want the 1940s experience recreation.gov
Candlelight Tour Wind 2 hr Strenuous 424 stairs, unlit route by candle bucket, 10 people max Older kids (8+) and adults who want atmosphere over distance Phone, 605-745-4600
Wild Cave Tour Wind Up to 4 hr Very strenuous Mostly crawling; fit through 10 in x 3 ft; 6 people max Fit adventurers 16+, clothes you can ruin Phone, 605-745-4600
Wild Caving Tour Jewel 3 to 4 hr Extremely strenuous Chimneying, rope climb, belly crawls; 8.5 x 24 in crawl block test Fit adventurers 16+ who pass the fit test recreation.gov request, closes 1 week ahead

Both caves sit in the Mountain time zone, so the tour times you see when booking are Mountain time. Fees run $6 to $16 for walking tours and $45 for the adventure tours; the reservation guide has the full fee table.

Which tour is best for a first cave tour?

For most first-timers the answer is the standard walking tour at whichever cave you visit: the Natural Entrance Tour at Wind Cave or the Scenic Tour at Jewel Cave. Both are the cave’s signature route, both run about an hour and a quarter, both are paved and lit, and both show the formations the cave is famous for without any crawling. The Scenic Tour has more stairs (734 of them) but enters and exits by elevator, so the climbing comes in stretches rather than stacked at one entrance.

If an hour and a quarter and a few hundred stairs sounds like a lot, the Garden of Eden Tour at Wind Cave is the shorter, gentler standard tour at about an hour and 150 stairs, and it samples all of Wind Cave’s formations: boxwork, cave popcorn, and flowstone. It is enough cave for many visitors.

Which tour is best with young kids?

It depends on the kid’s stamina and how they feel about the dark.

  • Youngest kids or short attention spans: Jewel Cave’s Discovery Tour, about 20 minutes in one big chamber, is the easy yes. It is also the only Jewel Cave tour that allows strollers, and the park recommends it for infants and toddlers.
  • Kids who can handle stairs and an hour underground: the Garden of Eden (Wind) or Scenic (Jewel) tour works well. Know the carry rule: children may not be carried on Jewel Cave tours, except an infant in a front carrier on the Scenic Tour, and every walker has to manage the stairs unassisted.
  • The low-light tours (Wind Cave Candlelight, Jewel Cave Historic Lantern) have a minimum age of 8 and trade lighting for atmosphere, so they suit older, steadier kids who will not be unsettled by the dark.
  • The adventure tours require age 16 and up and are not for children.

All tours are guided, so a ranger is with your group the whole time. Kids 15 and under need an adult along at Jewel Cave. And if the underground is a no-go, both parks run Junior Ranger programs on the surface; Jewel Cave even has a Pee Wee Ranger program for the smallest visitors.

Which tour is best for limited mobility, a wheelchair, or no stairs?

Each cave has a genuine no-stairs option, and they work differently:

  • Wind Cave Accessibility Tour: a dedicated, roughly 30-minute program that rides the elevator down to a level area of about 100 feet with zero stairs. It is wheelchair accessible, shows the cave’s signature boxwork, and costs just $6. Arrange it by phone at 605-745-4600 up to 3 days ahead; accessible parking is at the elevator building about 200 yards south of the visitor center. Sign-language interpreters are available with two weeks notice.
  • Jewel Cave Discovery Tour: the gentle option at Jewel: 20 minutes, elevator in and out, one large chamber. There are 15 steps to the lower platform; visitors needing step-free access can use the 37-foot upper concrete platform. If wheelchair specifics matter for your group, call 605-673-8300 before you book and the staff will talk you through it.
  • Discovery access details checked October 17, 2026 against the NPS tour description.

Every other tour at both caves involves hundreds of stairs and is not wheelchair accessible. The what-to-expect guide covers the accessibility details, stair counts, and what the parks provide at the surface.

Which tour is best if I am claustrophobic?

Stay on the developed walking tours and skip the adventure tours entirely. The standard tours at both caves follow wide, paved, lit, railed passages with a ranger and a group, and most people with mild claustrophobia are comfortable on them. The Discovery Tour at Jewel Cave (one open room, 20 minutes) is the least confining option if you want to test the waters first. Avoid the Wild Cave and Wild Caving tours, which involve deliberate crawling through tight, undeveloped passage; Jewel Cave says plainly that anyone with a fear of closed spaces or heights should not attempt its Wild Caving Tour. If tight spaces are a real worry, tell the ranger at the start; they do this every day.

Which is the hardest tour, and is the adventure tour worth it?

The hardest tour in either cave is an adventure tour: Wind Cave’s Wild Cave Tour (up to four hours, most of it spent crawling on hands and knees) and Jewel Cave’s Wild Caving Tour (3 to 4 hours the park rates extremely strenuous, with chimneying between walls, a rope-assisted climb up a near-vertical wall, and belly crawls through passages with names like the Brain Drain). Both require a minimum age of 16, clothes and boots you are willing to ruin, and $45. At Jewel Cave you must first pass through a concrete crawl block about 8.5 by 24 inches on the visitor center patio; if you cannot fit through the block, you cannot take the tour, and there is no refund.

Is it worth it? If you are reasonably fit, not claustrophobic, and you want to actually cave rather than walk through a cave, yes. It is the closest thing to wild caving you can do with a ranger and no prior experience. If you mainly want to see formations and stay clean, the standard tours show you more decorated passage with far less effort. Each cave books its adventure tour differently; the reservation guide covers exactly how.

Can I do both caves in one day?

Yes, and a lot of people do. The visitor centers connect by US 385 and US 16 through Custer. Check the drive for your travel day and leave room for wildlife delays and each park’s check-in time. Tours can sell out, so book both tours ahead (each park has its own recreation.gov page), leave yourself a comfortable gap between them for the drive and a meal in Custer, and check each park’s schedule the morning of in case a tour time shifts. If you only have energy for one cave plus other Black Hills stops, that is when the “which cave” breakdown at the top earns its keep.

Do not skip Jewel Cave

If you are weighing the two and leaning toward only Wind Cave because it is the national park and Jewel is “just” a monument, reconsider. Repeat visitors regularly rate Jewel Cave the more rewarding of the two underground, it is the fifth longest cave in the world with more than 220 miles of mapped passages, and it draws less of a crowd for the same reason it gets less hype. The Scenic Tour is the one to book if you want the cave at its most decorated. Both caves are worth a tour, and if your schedule allows the two-cave day, take it.

A note on Wind Cave’s deeper meaning

Wind Cave holds profound significance to the Lakota people, who understand it as a place of emergence. That story belongs to the Lakota and to the National Park Service interpretation, not to us, so we point you to nps.gov/wica and to the park’s cultural heritage rather than retelling it ourselves. It is worth reading before you visit.

Common questions about choosing a cave tour

Wind Cave or Jewel Cave: which is better?
Wind Cave wins above ground: a free surface park with bison, prairie, and scenic drives, plus more boxwork below than every other cave on Earth combined. Jewel Cave usually wins underground: it is the fifth longest cave in the world and the more decorated of the two. If you plan both, check the drive through Custer and leave room for each tour’s check-in time.
What is the best cave tour for a first-timer?
The Natural Entrance Tour at Wind Cave or the Scenic Tour at Jewel Cave. Both are the signature route at their cave, about an hour and a quarter, paved and lit, no crawling.
How many stairs are on each cave tour?
Wind Cave: Garden of Eden 150, Natural Entrance 300, Candlelight 424, Fairgrounds 450 (with one 89-step flight up), Accessibility Tour zero. Jewel Cave: Scenic 734, Historic Lantern about 600 steep and narrow ones, Discovery 15 steps to the lower platform, with a step-free upper platform available.
Which tour should someone with a fear of tight spaces take?
Any standard walking tour; the passages are wide, lit, and railed. Jewel Cave’s Discovery Tour is the least confining. Skip the Wild Cave and Wild Caving adventure tours, which are built around crawling through tight passages.
Can kids do the cave tours?
Yes. Standard tours have no minimum age (children 5 and under are free), the candlelight and lantern tours require age 8, and the adventure tours require age 16. Jewel Cave’s Discovery Tour allows strollers; on other Jewel tours children may not be carried, except infants in a front carrier on the Scenic Tour.
Do I need to book ahead?
In summer, yes. Wind Cave opens reservations 120 days ahead and Jewel Cave 30 to 60 days ahead, and summer tours sell out. See the full booking guide for windows, fees, same-day rules, and the separate adventure-tour process.

Keep exploring

Picked your tour? Here is exactly how to reserve it, and here is what to expect underground, from the 49-degree chill to the shoe rules. For the bigger picture, see the Wind Cave National Park and Jewel Cave National Monument guides, and the story of Jewel Cave passing 200 mapped miles.

Support the caves you are about to visit

Black Hills Parks & Forests Association is the nonprofit cooperating association at Wind Cave National Park and Jewel Cave National Monument. The visitor center bookstores, the online shop, and membership fund interpretation, education, and Junior Ranger programs at both parks. You can also donate or volunteer.

Donate or volunteer